THINK WITH ALEC

E-Commerce Platform in 2025: Trends, AI Impact, and Strategic Insights

Current Landscape

In the ever-evolving landscape of digital commerce, choosing the right e-commerce platform has become a high-stakes decision. The Gartner Magic Quadrant for Digital Commerce (2019) remains a solid foundation for understanding vendor capabilities, but a lot has changed since then.

AI has emerged as a transformative force, B2B commerce has grown more complex, and businesses of all sizes are demanding more from their platforms: faster time to market, better scalability, and seamless integration across channels.

This post will discuss what to consider when selecting an e-commerce platform—whether a small business or a global enterprise, and how AI, cost, scalability, and ecosystem maturity should factor into your decision. Let’s dive in.

1. Key Takeaways from Gartner’s Magic Quadrant (2019)

Gartner identified leaders such as:

  • Salesforce
  • Adobe (Magento)
  • SAP
  • Oracle

Each had strengths in platform scalability, global support, and B2B/B2C capabilities. Others like BigCommerce, Shopify, and commercetools showed promise for innovation, speed, and flexibility—especially for SMBs and mid-market companies.

Gartner’s Strategic Predictions for 2023:

  • 80% of AI-enabled commerce orgs would see at least 25% performance gains.
  • 15% of mid-to-high GMV organizations would deploy marketplaces.
  • 75% of D2C brands would offer subscriptions—only 20% would see meaningful retention gains.

Spoiler alert: many of these trends have not only played out—they’ve accelerated.

2. What’s Changed Since 2019

💡 Platform Trends

  • Headless commerce has gone mainstream, with more platforms embracing API-first approaches.
  • Composable commerce now dominates enterprise conversations, allowing brands to cherry-pick best-of-breed services.
  • AI/ML is embedded across search, product recommendations, fraud prevention, and customer service.
  • Omnichannel integration is no longer a nice-to-have; it’s a requirement.

⚠️ Market Shakeups

  • Shopify became a dominant force among SMBs and lean enterprise units.
  • Salesforce doubled down on integrations with MuleSoft and Customer 360.
  • Magento rebranded to Adobe Commerce and refocused on cloud-native enterprise features.
  • Headless-first platforms like commercetools and Elastic Path gained traction among digital-native brands.

3. AI’s Impact on E-Commerce Platforms

AI is no longer a buzzword—it’s baked into high-performing platforms in the following ways:

🔍 Personalized Search & Product Discovery

AI-powered search helps convert intent into sales. Think “You might also like…” powered by machine learning.

📦 Inventory Forecasting

Demand prediction algorithms help manage stock, avoid overselling, and reduce markdowns.

📈 Dynamic Pricing

Real-time market-driven pricing adjustments are helping brands stay competitive.

🤖 Chatbots & CX Automation

AI chatbots powered by LLMs (like GPT) are now handling tier-1 support and product guidance.

🧠 AI in Headless/Composable Architectures

Many headless systems are now bundling or partnering with AI tools (e.g., Bloomreach with commercetools, Adobe Sensei with Adobe Commerce).

4. Core Considerations by Business Size

For Small to Mid-Size Businesses (SMBs)

  • Top Priorities: Cost-effectiveness, time to market, ease of use, out-of-the-box features.
  • Recommended Platforms: Shopify, BigCommerce, WooCommerce (for content-first brands).
  • Key Considerations:
    • Can your team launch and run the platform without engineers?
    • Does it integrate easily with marketing tools (email, social, CRM)?
    • Is the payment gateway competitive?

Example: Allbirds, a DTC footwear brand, started on Shopify and scaled up with Shopify Plus as it expanded globally.

For Mid-Market Companies

  • Top Priorities: Flexibility, B2B/B2C hybrid capabilities, headless options, extensibility.
  • Recommended Platforms: BigCommerce (Open SaaS), Adobe Commerce, commercetools, Elastic Path.
  • Key Considerations:
    • Can you easily extend the platform as you grow?
    • Is there native support for B2B features (e.g., custom pricing, account management)?
    • Is the API ecosystem mature?

Example: Skullcandy moved to BigCommerce to improve site performance, gain multi-storefront control, and enable rapid A/B testing.

For Enterprise Businesses

  • Top Priorities: Scalability, composability, globalization support, deep integrations (ERP, CRM, OMS).
  • Recommended Platforms: Salesforce Commerce Cloud, SAP Commerce Cloud, Oracle Commerce Cloud, commercetools.
  • Key Considerations:
    • Is the platform enterprise-grade with proven uptime and SLAs?
    • Can it support a complex catalog, global currencies, and multi-site operations?
    • How mature is the vendor’s AI stack?

Example: L’Oréal uses Salesforce Commerce Cloud globally to power multiple brands with robust personalization and regionalization.

5. Platform Comparison Highlights

PlatformIdeal ForStrengthsWeaknesses
Shopify/Shopify PlusSMBs to lower enterpriseFast launch, ease of use, strong ecosystemLimited backend extensibility, weaker B2B
BigCommerceMid-marketOpen SaaS, strong B2B features, headlessLimited complex customizations
Adobe CommerceMid-market to enterpriseRich integrations (Adobe Suite), personalizationRequires dev resources, higher cost
Salesforce Commerce CloudEnterpriseBest-in-class integrations, global reachExpensive, complex implementation
commercetoolsDigital-native enterprisesHeadless, composable, fast deploymentRequires frontend dev, not plug-and-play
Elastic PathDevelopers, API-first orgsHyper-flexible, headless + PWA-readyNeeds technical expertise
SAP Commerce CloudLarge, SAP-heavy orgsDeep ERP integrations, industry acceleratorsHigh cost, complex upgrades

6. Final Recommendations

Whether you’re a boutique retailer or a Fortune 500 brand, platform selection matters more than ever. AI and automation are now table stakes, not futuristic features. Here’s how to approach your decision:

✅ For SMBs

Go with a platform that reduces overhead. Look for built-in features like abandoned cart recovery, marketing automation, and mobile-ready themes. Shopify and BigCommerce remain safe bets.

✅ For Mid-Market

Choose a scalable platform with solid APIs, moderate TCO, and B2B/B2C flexibility. Adobe Commerce and BigCommerce are strong picks, with commercetools and Elastic Path offering more tech-driven flexibility.

✅ For Enterprise

Prioritize composability, AI integration, and global extensibility. Salesforce Commerce Cloud and SAP Commerce Cloud lead here, while commercetools is ideal for teams ready to embrace headless architecture.

Looking Ahead

In 2025 and beyond, e-commerce platforms must:

  • Power marketplaces, subscriptions, and social commerce.
  • Seamlessly connect with AI-driven tools.
  • Offer composable architecture to meet ever-changing customer expectations.

The best choice is not necessarily the biggest or newest—it’s the one aligned with your business model, growth trajectory, and operational maturity.

Leave a comment